Chef Colt Taylor Reimagines the Historic James Pharmacy
Posted On : July 13, 2026
It’s hard to keep up with Chef Colt Taylor of The Essex. He’s always dreaming up something new, and his latest creation is the reinvented James Pharmacy. We mourned the closure of our favorite French lunch spot, Cocotte, and now we’re happy to find his inventive spirit fill the historic space. Imagine a butcher shop and sandwich counter rolled into one, stocked with gourmet oils, chili crunch, specialty rices, and penny candy, alongside cult-favorite Made In cookware (Colt’s favorite) and a striking display of knives in every shape and size. Their signature ice-cream-and-gelato hybrid is churned fresh daily. But the real showstopper? An honest-to-goodness hot pastrami sandwich. I almost never indulge, since the real deal was always missing here, but this one is irresistible: tender, peppery house-made pastrami, sliced thin and piled high, slathered with mustard on rye (of course).
Planning a barbecue? Prepare to be tempted by an array of unexpected meats, from wagyu hot dogs and Snake River Farms brisket to succulent skirt steaks, Long Island duck, and Hudson River chickens.
Swing by for beach-ready sandwiches, a golden rotisserie chicken with daily sides for dinner, or a stash of rib-eyes for your freezer. And do not miss a scoop of the freshly churned ice cream with a drizzle of Thyme Butterscotch sauce.
323 Main Street, Old Saybrook
Tues – Sat 11-6pm
Sun 11-4pm







